“Face detection in untrained deep neural networks” by Baek, S., Song, M., Jang, J. et al. 

Original article: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-27606-9

I do love this work for many reasons! 

Summary

It demonstrates that face-selectivity can emerge from untrained deep neural networks, whose weights are randomly initialized.  

The author found that units selective to faces emerge robustly in randomly initialized networks and that these units reproduce many characteristics observed in monkeys. ( They only claimed that their results aligned with other studies for face-selectivity in monkeys )

Scientific importance

I think that this work provides some suggestions to the following questions:

Whether this neuronal selectivity can arise innately or whether it requires training from the visual experience?

Where do innate cognitive functions in both biological and artificial neural networks come from?

“These findings may provide insight into the origin of innate cognitive functions
in both biological and artificial neural networks.”

Is face-selectivity a particular type of neuronal properties or is selectivity one common property for face and other objects?

I partially agree with this work that selectivity is one common property for faces and other objects. However, I also believe that “face” is also special in terms of playing a key role in social interaction.

My question

However, I still do not know how technically (or physically or biologically) it could develop face-selectivity in untrained deep neural networks (or in a primate brain).

Do you think that the key factor for the development of the “phenomena” is the feed-forward connections rather than the statistical complexity embedded in each hierarchical circuit? Or maybe both?

Reference:

Baek, S., Song, M., Jang, J. et al. Face detection in untrained deep neural networks. Nat Commun 12, 7328 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-27606-9